| DATE | LOCATION | DIRECTOR | ACCOMPANISTS | SOLOISTS | SPEAKERS |
| Dec. 16, 1945 | First Methodist Church | Mrs. William J. Caldwell | Edwin Lewis Organist ---------- Mrs. Richard K. Allen Pianist |
Mrs. Edward
C. O'Neill Soprano ---------- Mrs. James A. Rugh Contralto ---------- Mr. Erwin Bendel Tenor ---------- Mr. Delbert I. Fletcher Bass |
Rev. Burr
R. McKnight, D. D. Invocation ---------- Rev. R. M. Patterson Offertory ---------- Rev. A. E. Simon Benediction |
| Dec. 9, 1956 | The Scottish Rite Cathedral | Mrs. William J. Caldwell | Edwin Lewis Organist ---------- Kathryne Allen Pianist |
Alice Andrews Soprano ---------- Nancy Williams Contralto ---------- Robert Topping Tenor ---------- Earl Corwin Bass |
Rev. Lynn
A. Shindledecker Invocation ---------- Dr. Jennings B. Reid Offertory ---------- Dr. Gene Stone Benediction |
| Dec. 7, 1958 | The Scottish Rite Cathedral | Mrs. William J. Caldwell | Edwin Lewis Organist ---------- Kathryne Allen Pianist |
Alice Long
Walker Soprano ---------- Nancy Williams Contralto ---------- William Cover Tenor ---------- Earl Corwin Bass |
Rev. Rosamond
C. Kay, Jr. Invocation ---------- Rev. Henry B. Strock Offertory ---------- Rev. H. H. McConnel Benediction |
| Dec. 13, 1959 | The Scottish Rite Cathedral | Mrs. William J. Caldwell | Edwin Lewis Organist ---------- Kathryne Allen Pianist |
Alice Long
Walker Soprano ---------- Anne Braun Mast Contralto ---------- John Paton Tenor ---------- Earl Corwin Bass |
Rev. Harold
P. Albright Invocation ---------- Rev. Samuel L. Fleming Offertory ---------- Dr. Gene Stone Benediction |
| Dec. 4, 1960 | The Scottish Rite Cathedral | Mrs. W. Walter Braham | Edwin Lewis Organist ---------- Kathryne Allen Pianist |
Alice Long
Walker Soprano ---------- Anne Braun Mast Contralto ---------- John Affleck Tenor ---------- Earl Corwin Bass |
Rev. Harold
P. Albright Invocation ---------- Rev. Cuyler N. Ferguson Offertory ---------- Rev. Howard J. Landes Benediction |
| Dec. 9, 1962 | The Scottish Rite Cathedral | Mrs. W. Walter Braham | Edwin Lewis Organist ---------- Kathryne Allen Pianist |
Alice Long
Walker Soprano ---------- Anne Braun Mast Contralto ---------- Hamilton Beck Tenor ---------- Earl Corwin Bass |
Dr. Gene
Stone Invocation ---------- Rev. Delbert Jolley Offertory ---------- Rev. Richard Price Benediction |
| Dec. 8, 1963 | The Scottish Rite Cathedral | Mrs. W. Walter Braham | Edwin Lewis Organist ---------- Ruth Weir Pianist |
Alice Long
Walker Soprano ---------- Anne Braun Mast Contralto ---------- John Affleck Tenor ---------- Earl Corwin Bass |
Rev. Delbert
Jolley Invocation ---------- Dr. Gene Stone Offertory ---------- Rev. V. Theordore Benson Benediction |
| Dec. 6, 1964 | The Scottish Rite Cathedral | Mrs. W. Walter Braham | Edwin Lewis Organist ---------- Ruth Weir Pianist |
Alice Long
Walker Soprano ---------- Anne Braun Mast Contralto ---------- John Affleck Tenor ---------- IWilbur G. Dumbaugh Bass |
Edwin Lewis
Invocation ---------- Rev. Mervin Schwab Offertory ---------- Rev. Edwin T. Cochran, Jr. Benediction |
| Dec. 12, 1971 | The First
United Methodist Church |
Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Edwin Lewis Organist ---------- Ruth Weir Pianist |
Mrs. George
W. Schuller Soprano ---------- Mrs. Cargill G. McConnell Contralto ---------- Lynn Fowler Tenor ---------- Isaac Reid Bass |
Dr. George
W. Henderson Invocation ---------- Rev. Russell E. Perry Offertory ---------- Dr. George W. Henderson Benediction |
| Dec. 3, 1972 | The Nortminster
United Presbyterian Church |
Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Miss Ruth
Weir Pianist |
Mary Ann
Klussman Soprano ---------- Joyce Johns Fowler Contralto ---------- Kenneth Phillips Tenor ---------- Frederick Horst Bass |
Dr. George
W. Henderson Invocation ---------- Rev. John Sloat Offertory ---------- Dr. George W. Henderson Benediction |
| Dec. 2, 1973 | The Clen-Moore
United Presbyterian Chruch |
Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist |
Nancy Brown Soprano ---------- Mrs. Louis J. Walls Contralto ---------- Kenvin R. Moreau Tenor ---------- Donald E. Wallace Bass |
Rev Harris
S. McSkimming Invocation ---------- Rev. Jack F. Heinsoln Offertory ---------- Rev Harris S. McSkimming Benediction |
| Dec. 1, 1974 | The First Baptist Church | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Ruth Weir Pianist |
Rosanne
Maiorano Soprano ---------- Mrs. James W. McAnlis Contralto ---------- Kenneth Phillips Tenor ---------- Frederick Horst Bass |
Rev. Calvin
S. Merritt Invocation ---------- Rev. Donald G. Cochran Offertory ---------- Rev. Calvin S. Merritt Benediction |
| Nov. 30, 1975 | The First Baptist Church | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist |
Bardarah
McCandless Soprano ---------- Joyce Johns Fowler Contralto ---------- Bruce Montgomery Tenor ---------- James E. McKeel, Jr. Bass |
Rodney
D. Larson Invocation ---------- Rev. Lorne J. Lee Offertory ---------- Monsignor Joseph F. Fabbri Benediction |
| Nov. 28, 1976 | The First Baptist Church | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist |
Mrs. Durward
A. Newhard ---------- Soprano Mrs. William J. Turner Soprano ---------- Nancy Matheny Contralto ---------- Lynn D. Fowler Tenor ---------- Brian W.Ocock Bass |
Rev. Calvin
S. Merritt Invocation ---------- Rev. Vernon C. Borchert Offertory ---------- Rev. Thomas Tobin Benediction |
| Nov. 27, 1977 | The First Baptist Church | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist |
Bonnie Jean Fenton Soprano ---------- Mrs. James W. MacAnlis Contralto ---------- Kenneth Phillips Tenor ---------- Frederick Horst Bass |
Rev. Calvin
S. Merritt Invocation ---------- Offertory ---------- Rev. James A. Downs Benediction |
| Dec. 3, 1978 | The First Baptist Church | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist |
Joanne Dudek Soprano ---------- Nancy Matheny Contralto ---------- Mark John Tenor ---------- Wilbur G. Dumbaugh Bass |
Rev. Franklin
D. Bishop Invocation ---------- Offertory ---------- Father Vincent C. Bertoline Benediction |
| Dec. 2, 1979 | The First Baptist Church | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist |
Joanne
Dudek Soprano ---------- Joyce Johns Fowler Mezzo Soprano ---------- Eric W. Bower Tenor ---------- Brian W. Ocock Bass |
Dr. Hugh
D. Anderson Invocation ---------- Offertory ---------- Rev. Carl Sacherich, Jr. Benediction |
| Nov. 30, 1980 | The First Baptist Church | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist |
Diana Walters Soprano ---------- Nancy Matheny Contralto ---------- Burce Montgomery Tenor ---------- Paul G. Verner Bass |
Dr. Hugh
D. Anderson Invocation ---------- Dr. Hugh D. Anderson Offertory ---------- Dr. Hugh D. Anderson Benediction |
| Nov. 29, 1981 | The First Baptist Church | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist |
Rosanne
C. Palladino Soprano ---------- Mrs. James W. McAnlis Contralto ---------- Mark John Izzo Tenor ---------- Frederick Horst Bass |
Dr. Robet
A. Veitch Invocation ---------- Dr. Robet A. Veitch Offertory ---------- Dr. Robet A. Veitch Benediction |
| Nov. 28, 1982 | The First Baptist Church | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist |
Joanne
Dudek Soprano ---------- Judith Hughes Mezzo Soprano ---------- Bruce Montgomery Tenor ---------- Kris Harper Bass |
Rev. John
W. Lyons Invocation ---------- Rev. John W. Lyons Offertory ---------- Rev. John W. Lyons Benediction |
| Move. 27, 1983 | The First Baptist Church | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- |
Joanne
Dudek Soprano ---------- Nancy Matheny Contralto ---------- Dr. Kenneth H. Phillips Tenor ---------- John R. Clark Bass |
Rev. David
Bell Invocation ---------- Rev. David Bell Offertory ---------- Rev. David Bell Benediction |
| Nov. 25, 1984 | The First Baptist Church | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist |
Rosanne
Palladino Soprano ---------- Joyce Johns Fowler Mezzo Soprano ---------- William C. Hite Tenor ---------- Frederick Horst Bass |
Rev. Blanchard
Romaine, III Invocation ---------- Rev. Blanchard Romaine, III Offertory ---------- Rev. Blanchard Romaine, III Benediction |
| Dec. 1, 1985 | Will W. Orr Auditorium | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist |
Joanne
McFarland Soprano ---------- Joyce Johns Fowler Mezzo Soprano ---------- Bruce Montgomery Tenor ---------- Brian W. Ocock Bass |
Rev. Daniel
R. Orris Invocation ---------- Rev. Daniel R. Orris Offertory ---------- Rev. William E. White Benediction |
| Nov. 30, 1986 | Will W. Orr Auditorium | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist |
Rosanne
Palladino Soprano ---------- Nancy Matheny Contralto ---------- Bruce Montgomery Tenor ---------- Harry B. Budd Bass |
Rev. Herbert
Zook Invocation ---------- Rev. Herbert Zook Offertory ---------- Dr. Timothy L. Beal Benediction |
| Nov. 29, 1987 | Will W. Orr Auditorium | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist ---------- Amy Remaley Trumpeter |
Joanne
McFarland Soprano ---------- Judith Hughes Mezzo Soprano ---------- Jody Patrick Tenor ---------- Kris Harper Bass |
Rev. Dennis
R. Davenport Invocation ---------- Rev. Dennis R. Davenport Offertory ---------- Rev. Herbert Zook Benediction |
| Nov. 27, 1988 | Will W. Orr Auditorium | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist ---------- Chris A. Masi Trumpeter |
Julianne
E. Hoge Soprano ---------- Lisa Temple Mezzo Soprano ---------- Bruce Montgomery Tenor ---------- John R. Clark Bass |
Rev. Dennis
R. Davenport Invocation ---------- Rev. Dennis R. Davenport Offertory ---------- Rev. Dennis R. Davenport Benediction |
| Nov. 26, 1989 | Will W. Orr Auditorium | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist ---------- Chris A. Masi Trumpeter |
Desi Madrid
Murberger Soprano ---------- Judith Hughes Mezzo Soprano ---------- Christopher Fox Tenor ---------- Frederick Horst Bass |
Rev. Dennis
R. Davenport Invocation ---------- Rev. Dennis R. Davenport Offertory ---------- Rev. Dennis R. Davenport Benediction |
| Nov. 25. 1990 | Will W. Orr Auditorium | Mrs. Kenneth W. Gibson | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Miss Ruth Weir Pianist ---------- Gerald Maxwell Trumpeter |
Rosanne
Palladino Soprano ---------- Judith Hughes Mezzo Soprano ---------- Bruce Montgomery Tenor ---------- Frederick Horst Bass |
Rev. Dennis
R. Davenport Invocation ---------- Rev. Dennis R. Davenport Offertory ---------- Rev. Dennis R. Davenport Benediction |
| Dec. 1, 1991 | Will W. Orr Auditorium | Harry M. Cunningham | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Ruth Weir Pianist ---------- Gerald Maxwell Trumpeter |
Joanne
McFarland Soprano ---------- Lisa Temple Alto ---------- Bruce Montgomery Tenor ---------- Milutin Lazich Bass |
Rev. Mark
S. Davis Invocation ---------- Rev. George Yates Offertory ---------- Rev. Mark S. Davis Benediction |
| Nov. 29, 1992 | Will W. Orr Auditorium | Harry M. Cunningham | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Sondra Firle Principal Pianist ---------- Kathleen R. Lynam Pianist ---------- Gerald Maxwell Trumpeter |
Gail Glenn
Varine Soprano ---------- Elaine Walls Reed Alto ---------- Guy Russo Tenor ---------- Brian W. Ocock Bass |
Rev. Charles
Christian Invocation ---------- REv. Henk Bossers Offertory ---------- Rev. Charles Christian Benediction |
| Nov. 28, 1993 | Will W. Orr Auditorium | Harry M. Cunningham | Raymond
H. Ocock Organist ---------- Sondra Firle Pianist ---------- Kathleen R. Lynam Pianist ---------- Gerald Maxwell Trumpeter |
Colleen
Neubert Soprano ---------- Janice Wilson Alto ---------- William Hite Tenor ---------- Donald J. Rasely Bass |
Rev. Mark
S. Davis Invocation ---------- Father Frank Erdlejac Offertory ---------- Rev. Mark S. Davis Benediction |
| Nov. 27, 1994 | The First Baptist Church | Harry M. Cunningham | Dr. Richard
A. Konzen Organist ---------- Kathleen R. Lynam Pianist |
Joanne
McFarland Soprano ---------- Diana Walters Alto ---------- Bruce Montgomery Tenor ---------- Curt Scheib Bass |
Rev. Mark
S. Davis Invocation ---------- Rev. Dennis Bupp Offertory ---------- Rev. Ron Eade Benediction |
| Nov. 26, 1995 | The First Baptist Church | Harry M. Cunningham | Dr. Richard
A. Konzen Organist ---------- Kathleen R. Lynam Pianist ---------- James Cunningham Trumpeter |
Joanne
McFarland Soprano ---------- Jodi Miklas Alto ---------- William Hite Tenor ---------- Dr. Christopher Lyle Bass |
Rev. Andrew
Jillson Invocation ---------- Rev. Tom Rutherford Offertory ---------- Rev. Mark S. Davis Benediction |
| Nov. 30, 1996 | The Third Baptist Church (Youngstown) | Harry M. Cunningham | Carol Lundberg Organist ---------- Karen McElhaney Pianist ---------- James Cunningham Trumpeter |
Joanne
McFarland Soprano ---------- Jodi Miklas Alto ---------- Bruce Montgomery Tenor ---------- John Clark Bass |
Rev. Morris
W. Lee Invocation ---------- Rev. Morris W. Lee Offertory ---------- Rev. Morris W. Lee Benediction |
| Dec. 1, 1996 | The First Baptist Church | Harry M. Cunningham | Carol Lundberg Organist ---------- Karen McElhaney Pianist ---------- James Cunningham Trumpeter |
Joanne
McFarland Soprano ---------- Jodi Miklas Alto ---------- Bruce Montgomery Tenor ---------- John Clark Bass |
Rev. Doug
Van Niel Invocation ---------- Rev. Bill Schafer Offertory ---------- Rev. S.B. Allen Benediction |
| Nov. 30, 1997 | The First Baptist Church | Harry M. Cunningham | Carol Lundberg Organist ---------- Karen McElhaney Pianist ---------- Robert J. Ficca Trumpeter |
Joanne
McFarland Soprano ---------- Jodi Miklas Alto ---------- Christopher W. Waite Tenor ---------- Milutin Lazich Bass |
Rev. Pam
McKee Invocation ---------- Rev. Jerry Marshall Offertory ---------- Rev. Tom Rutherford Benediction |
| Nov. 28, 1998 | Penn State Shenango | Harry M. Cunningham | Joann Ceryan
DiLorenzo Organist ---------- Karen McElhaney Pianist ---------- James Cunningham Trumpeter |
Joni McFarland Soprano ---------- Jodi Miklas Alto ---------- Stephen Phillips Tenor ---------- Donald J. Rasely Bass |
Dr. Ferruccio
Germani Greeting ---------- Major Patricia Beeman Offertory ---------- Rev.Dr. Donald A. Aull Benediction |
| Nov. 29, 1998 | St. Camilus RomanCatholic Church | Harry M. Cunningham | Joann Ceryan
DiLorenzo Organist ---------- Karen McElhaney Pianist ---------- James Cunningham Trumpeter |
Joni McFarland Soprano ---------- Jodi Miklas Alto ---------- Stephen Phillips Tenor ---------- Donald J. Rasely Bass |
Father
Robert Miller Invocation ---------- Major Patricia Beeman Offertory ---------- Rev.Dr. Donald A. Aull Benediction |
| Nov. 28, 1999 | The Clen-Moore Presbyterian Chruch | Harry M. Cunningham | Joanne
Ceryan DiLorenzo Organist ---------- Karen McElhaney Pianist ---------- Stephen McKnight Trumpeter |
Diana Walters Soprano ---------- Lisa Temple Duckworth Alto ---------- Christopher W. Waite Tenor ---------- Allan R. Mosher Bass |
Rev. Velis
Vais Invocation ---------- Rev. Alan DeCristoforo Offertory ---------- Rev. Jerry Marshall Benediction |
| Dec. 10, 2000 | The Scottish Rite Cathedral | Harry M. Cunningham | Signe O.
Mitchell Organist ---------- Karen Toth Pianist ---------- Hardin T. Butcher Trumpeter |
Diana Walters Soprano ---------- Jodi Miklas Alto ---------- Bruce Montgomery Tenor ---------- Allan R. Mosher Bass |
Rev. Gary
R. Crowe Invocation ---------- Rev. William F. Schafer Offertory ---------- Rev. Dennis Bupp Benediction |
| Nov. 25, 2001 | The First Presbyterian Church | Harry M. Cunningham | Joann Ceryan
DiLorenzo Organist ---------- Karen Toth Pianist ---------- Jeff Smith Trumpeter |
Joni McFarland Soprano ---------- Jodi Miklas Alto ---------- Christopher Hamady Tenor ---------- Allan R. Mosher Bass |
Rev. Raymond
I. Hylton Invocation ---------- Rev. Mark Eberly Offertory ---------- Rev. Hope Cummins Benediction |
| Dec. 1, 2002 | The First
United Methodist Church |
Harry M. Cunningham | Nancy Wiand Organist ---------- Karen Toth Pianist ---------- Hardin T. Butcher Trumpeter |
Rosemary
Minghetti Soprano ---------- Lisa Duckworth Alto ---------- Bruce Montgomery Tenor ---------- James V. Piccirilli Bass |
Rev. S.
B. Allen Invocation ---------- Rev. William F. Schafer Offertory ---------- Rev. S.B. Allen Benediction |
| Nov. 30, 2003 | The First Christian Church | Harry M. Cunningham | Paula A.
Kubik Organist ---------- Karen Toth Pianist ---------- Hardin T. Butcher Trumpeter |
Joni McFarland Soprano ---------- Nathan Mohney Countertenor / Tenor ---------- James V. Piccirilli Bass |
Rev. Gary
R. Crowe Invocation ---------- Rev. William F. Schafer Offertory ---------- Rev. David Bell Benediction |
| Nov. 28, 2004 | St. Joseph, the Worker, Roman Catholic Church | Harry M. Cunningham | Paula A.
Kubik Organist ---------- Mary Lou Pruchnic Organist ---------- Karen Toth Pianist ---------- Sharon M. Perschke Trumpeter ---------- Timothy Tuite Flautist ---------- Justin D. Watt Timpanist |
Diana Walters Soprano ---------- Karen Campman Emmett Alto ---------- Robert Frankenberry Tenor ---------- Allan R. Mosher Bass |
Father
Robert J. Schweitzer Invocation ---------- Rev. James George Offertory ---------- Rev. James George Benediction |
| Nov. 27, 2005 | St. James, the Apostle, Roman Catholic Parish | Harry M. Cunningham | Kathryn
Gray Organist ---------- Karen Toth Pianist ---------- Matthew Buehler Trumpeter |
Joanne
McFarland Soprano ---------- Jodi Miklas Alto ---------- Bruce Montgomery Tenor ---------- John Clark Bass |
Father
John W. Rebel Invocation ---------- Rev. Rex A. Wasser Offertory ---------- Rev. Bill Beck Benediction |
| Nov. 26, 2006 | Mary, Mother of Hope Roman Catholic Parish | Harry M. Cunningham | Paula A.
Kubik Organist ---------- Nanette Kaplan Solomon Pianist ---------- Hardin T. Butcher Trumpeter ---------- Sharon M. Perschke Flautist ---------- Sarah Sexton Timpanist |
Rosemary
Minghetti Soprano ---------- Karen Campman Emmett Alto ---------- Robert Frankenberry Tenor ---------- Kris Harper Bass |
Rev. Victor
J. Molka Invocation ---------- Rev. James Dollhopf Offertory ---------- Rev. James Dollhopf Benediction |
| Nov. 25, 2007 | The Clen-Moore Presbyterian Chruch | Harry M. Cunningham | Kathy Miller Organist ---------- Karen Toth Pianist ---------- Sharon Perschke Flautist |
Courtney
McNeely Soprano ---------- Camille O'Connor Alto ---------- Nathan Mohney Tenor ---------- Zachery Luchette Bass Please see article |
Rev. Bill
Meyer Invocation ---------- Rev. William Schafer Offertory ---------- Rev. Andrew Jillson Benediction |
| Nov. 30, 2008 | Epworth United Methodist Church | Harry M. Cunningham | Kathy Miller Organist ---------- Karen Toth Pianist ---------- Andrew Erb Trumpeter |
Joanne McFarland Soprano ---------- Camille O'Connor Alto ---------- Guy Russo Tenor ---------- James Piccirilli Bass |
Rev. Rex
A. Wasser Invocation ---------- Rev. Dr. Raymond Hylton Offertory ---------- Rev. Hope Cummins Benediction |
| Nov. 29, 2009 | St. Vincent de Paul Roman Catholic Parish | Harry M. Cunningham | Kathy Miller Organist ---------- Karen Toth Pianist ---------- Andrew Erb Trumpeter |
Jennifer
McMurdy Soprano ---------- Camille O'Connor Alto ---------- James Cochran Tenor ---------- Bruce Montgomery Tenor ---------- Zachary Luchette Bass |
Father Steven
M. Palsa Invocation ---------- Reverend Matthew Bupp Offertory ---------- Reverend Hope Cummins Benediction |